← Back to Insights

Feel-Good Isn't Sell-Good: Which Emotions Drive Purchase Intent in Retail Creator Content

Christmas ad season always gets our industry talking about what makes advertising work, and whether making people happy is enough. So we looked at our own data on retail creator content. The videos that made people smile most were not the ones that made them want to buy.

Feel-Good Isn't Sell-Good: Which Emotions Drive Purchase Intent in Retail Creator Content

Key Takeaways

  • We looked at which emotions in retail creator content go with higher purchase intent.
  • The videos that made people smile the most delivered about a third less purchase intent than the same retailer's other videos.
  • The sweet spot was a touch of heart: bittersweet videos drove the strongest uplift in purchase intent.
  • A bit of edge helps too: videos with some tension delivered nearly twice the purchase intent of those with none.
  • Smiles are lovely, but if you want people to buy, give them something to feel, not just something to smile at.

Christmas ad season is always a great moment for our industry to talk about what makes advertising work. Every year the same question comes up: if people come away happy, has the ad done its job?

It got us thinking about the role different emotions play in driving results. So we looked at our own data on retail creator content.

Do happy ads drive more purchase intent?

Not on their own. In retail creator content, the videos that made people smile the most delivered about a third less purchase intent than the same retailer's other videos.

That comparison matters. It's the same retailer, so the gap isn't about the brand. It's about what the video made people feel.

Feel-good vs sell-goodEmotion and purchase intent in retail creator content.
  1. Most smilesFeels good
    • About a third less purchase intent than the same retailer's other videos
  2. Heart and edgeSells
    • Bittersweet: the strongest uplift in purchase intent
    • Some tension: nearly twice the purchase intent of none

Source: Element Human retail creator content tests, emotion measured by facial coding.

Which emotions sell in retail advertising?

A touch of heart. The sweet spot was bittersweet. Bittersweet videos drove the strongest uplift in purchase intent.

A bit of edge. Videos with some tension delivered nearly twice the purchase intent of those with none.

This lines up with what we've seen elsewhere. In retail, happiness slightly lowers trust, and smiles alone don't sell credibility. Read the emotion and trust analysis.

What should retailers do with this?

  1. Don't stop at a smile. Making people happy is lovely, but on its own it isn't what makes them want to buy.
  2. Add some heart. A bittersweet moment gave the strongest uplift in purchase intent.
  3. Allow a little tension. Some edge nearly doubled purchase intent compared with none.
  4. Measure the emotion, not just the reaction. Facial coding shows what people actually felt, second by second, so you can see which moments sell.

Smiles are lovely. But if you want people to buy, give them something to feel, not just something to smile at.

How we measured this

For this analysis we looked at retail creator content, comparing each video with the same retailer's other videos. We measured emotion through facial coding while people watched, and purchase intent as the uplift against a control group, with around 150 exposed viewers and 100 control viewers per test. Element Human also tests brand ads as well as creator content, across social feeds (TikTok, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube Shorts), CTV pre-rolls and sponsorships in simulated streaming environments, and standalone video such as TV ads. Every test compares an exposed group with a control group of people who did not see the content.

About the author

Hamish McPharlin is Chief Customer Officer at Element Human, where he helps brands prove and optimise the impact of their advertising. He previously worked at the BBC and CNN. Follow Hamish on LinkedIn.

Want to gather your own insights?

Ellie is your decision partner for marketing. Ask about attention, emotion and brand memory inside Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini Enterprise, and get answers from real human reaction data.

Try Ellie

Frequently asked questions

Do happy ads drive purchase intent?
Not on their own. In Element Human data on retail creator content, the videos that made people smile the most delivered about a third less purchase intent than the same retailer's other videos.
Which emotions drive purchase intent in retail advertising?
A touch of heart and a bit of edge. Bittersweet videos drove the strongest uplift in purchase intent, and videos with some tension delivered nearly twice the purchase intent of those with none.
How does Element Human measure emotion in ads?
With webcam-based facial coding, second by second, while people watch. We then compare brand outcomes such as purchase intent between people who saw the content and a control group who did not.

See what your audience actually feels

Independent media intelligence for your next campaign.

Meet With Us